What Business Are You Really In?

Why Theodore Levitt's 1960 theory could transform the way every small business thinks about marketing
One of the biggest misconceptions about marketing is that it begins once you have a product or service to sell. Many business owners spend months perfecting their offer, designing a logo, building a website and creating social media content before asking themselves a far more important question:
Does anybody actually want this, and if so, why?
It is an understandable way of thinking. After all, if you have invested your time, money and expertise into creating something, the next logical step appears to be finding customers to buy it. However, one of the most influential pieces of marketing theory ever written suggests this approach has the process completely back to front.

In 1960, Harvard Business School professor Theodore Levitt published an article called Marketing Myopia ('Shortsightedness'). More than sixty-five years later, it remains one of the foundations of modern marketing thinking. Levitt argued that businesses rarely struggle because they make poor products. Instead, businesses struggle because they become so focused on those products that they lose sight of the customer need they exist to satisfy.

His famous example was the American railway industry. Railway companies believed they were in the railway business. Levitt argued they were actually in the transportation business. Because they defined themselves by trains rather than by helping people travel from one place to another, they were slow to respond as cars and airlines transformed the way people moved around the country.
Although Levitt was writing about large corporations, I believe his ideas are even more relevant for today's solopreneurs and micro businesses.
Meet Jenny
Imagine Jenny owns a small artisan jam business in Norfolk. She spends hours perfecting recipes, carefully selecting fruit, designing beautiful labels and photographing every new flavour for Instagram. Her products regularly receive compliments at local markets and she genuinely believes she has one of the best products available.

Yet sales have started to slow.
She doesn't know why. Jenny's first instinct is the same as many business owners. She blames the Instagram algorithm. Perhaps she needs a new logo. Maybe she should spend more on Facebook advertising or redesign her website.
These are common reactions, but Levitt would probably stop her before she spent a single pound.
He wouldn't ask, "How do we sell more jam?"
He would ask, "Why do people buy your jam in the first place?"
That single question changes everything.
Jenny believes she's selling jam.
Her customers might see something completely different.
Some buy her products because they make thoughtful gifts.
Others want to support local producers.
Some enjoy creating memorable breakfasts with their family on a Sunday morning.
Others simply want to treat themselves to something a little more special than supermarket alternatives.
The jam is simply the vehicle through which those needs are met.
Once Jenny starts thinking this way, entirely new opportunities begin to appear. Instead of simply developing more flavours, she could create luxury gift hampers, breakfast subscription boxes, corporate thank-you gifts, seasonal collections or locally sourced picnic hampers. None of these ideas starts with the product. They all begin with understanding the customer.
That is exactly what Levitt meant by avoiding marketing myopia.
Marketing starts before the product
When I first started learning marketing, I imagined it literally meant taking your products to market. You make something, package it beautifully, drive to the local farmers' market and spend the day trying to persuade people to buy it.
Levitt completely flips that thinking.
Marketing doesn't begin when you arrive at the market.
It begins long before you've even decided what you're going to sell.
The process should look something like this:
Who are we trying to help?
What problem are they trying to solve?
What outcome do they really want?
What solution could we create?
How can we communicate why we're different?
Only then should we think about websites, advertising, social media or content.
How You Can Use Levitt's Theory In Your Business
The easiest way to spot marketing myopia is to listen to how a business describes itself. Most owners instinctively talk about what they do rather than the value they create. The exercise below demonstrates how a small change in thinking can completely transform a business's positioning. More importantly, it reveals opportunities that many businesses never even consider.
The final column asks what I think is Levitt's most powerful question:
If your current product or service disappeared tomorrow, how else could you solve the same customer problem?
Business | What they think they sell | What the customer is actually buying | Customer-focused positioning | If this disappeared tomorrow... |
Septic tank company | Septic tank emptying | Peace of mind, compliance and avoiding expensive emergencies. | We help rural homeowners keep their wastewater systems safe, compliant and worry-free. | Servicing plans, inspections, drainage maintenance, water testing, emergency call-outs and environmental advice. |
Financial adviser | Pensions and investments | Financial confidence, security and better life decisions. | We help people make confident financial decisions so they can enjoy life with greater security. | Retirement coaching, financial education, inheritance planning, cashflow coaching and life planning. |
Commercial photographer | Photography | Trust, credibility and stronger brands. | We help businesses build trust and win more customers through authentic visual storytelling. | Video, employer branding, personal branding, LinkedIn consultancy and brand storytelling. |
Bespoke kitchen company | Kitchens | A home people love living in and sharing with family. | We create spaces where families cook, connect and make memories. | Utility rooms, home offices, fitted furniture, storage solutions and interior design. |
Commercial wheelie bin company | Waste collections | Reliability, compliance and one less operational headache. | We help businesses stay clean, compliant and focused on running their business—not worrying about waste. | Waste consultancy, ESG reporting, sustainability advice, recycling audits and compliance training. |
Wellness sauna | Sauna sessions | Better wellbeing, recovery and stress relief. | We help busy people feel healthier, calmer and more energised. | Cold-water therapy, breathwork, massage, recovery coaching and corporate wellbeing programmes. |
Marketing consultant | Marketing | Clarity, confidence and better business decisions. | I help business owners make smarter marketing decisions so they waste less time, money and energy. | Training, speaking, mentoring, strategy facilitation, books, research and online courses. |
Jam maker | Artisan jam | Thoughtful gifts and memorable food experiences. | We help people create memorable food experiences and thoughtful gifts. | Gift hampers, picnic boxes, afternoon teas, preserves, recipe books and food experiences. |
There is an interesting pattern running through every example. None of these businesses is really defined by its product. The septic tank company is not actually in the septic tank business; it is in the peace-of-mind business. The commercial photographer is not in the photography business; they are in the trust-building business. The financial adviser is not in the pensions business; they are in the confidence business. Once you define your business by the problem you solve rather than the product you sell, innovation becomes much easier. You stop asking, "What else can I sell?" and start asking, "What else would help my customer achieve the same outcome?"
The Marketing Myopia Check
If your enquiries have slowed or your marketing feels harder than it used to, don't immediately assume you need to post more on social media or spend more on advertising.
Start by asking yourself these ten questions.
Can you describe the problem you solve without mentioning your product or service?
Have you spoken to customers about their needs in the last three months?
Do you know why customers choose you instead of your competitors?
Could your business survive if your current product or service disappeared?
Does your website focus more on customer outcomes than your own experience?
Do customers describe your value in the same way you do?
Are you measuring customer success rather than simply sales?
If enquiries have slowed, have you researched why before changing your marketing?
Can your ideal customer clearly explain why they should choose you?
Are you solving today's customer problems rather than yesterday's?
If you answered "no" to several of these questions, don't panic. Marketing myopia isn't a permanent condition. It is simply a reminder to become curious about your customers again.
What if you're not getting enough leads?
Many businesses respond to declining enquiries by posting more often on social media, redesigning their website or increasing their advertising budget. Those activities might help, but only if the underlying problem is visibility.
Sometimes the real issue is much deeper.
Customer priorities may have changed. Competitors may have repositioned themselves. Your offer may no longer solve the problem people care most about. Or perhaps your business has simply become difficult to distinguish from everyone else.
Before changing your marketing, ask yourself one question:
Have I become more focused on what I sell than why people buy it?
If the honest answer is yes, no amount of posting on LinkedIn or Instagram is likely to solve the problem.
The lesson every small business can learn
One of the biggest dangers for owner-managed businesses is that we become emotionally attached to our expertise. We proudly describe ourselves as photographers, accountants, web designers, coaches or consultants because that's what we spend every day doing.
Our customers don't see us that way.
They see us as the people who solve a problem, remove a frustration or help them achieve something important.
The photographer helps businesses build trust.
The accountant provides peace of mind.
The waste company gives business owners one less thing to worry about.
The financial adviser creates confidence about the future.
The marketing consultant helps business owners make smarter decisions.
The service is simply the means by which that outcome is delivered.
Perhaps that is the enduring lesson from Levitt's work. Marketing is not about finding customers for the products we have already created. It is about understanding people well enough to create products and services they genuinely value.
So before you redesign your logo, start another social media account or spend more money on advertising, ask yourself one simple question:
What business am I really in?
Your answer might completely change the way you think about marketing.
.png)



Comments