top of page

What Business Owners Can Learn From Morrisons: Being Perfectly Fine Is Not A Marketing Strategy

Writer: Rechenda Smith
Rechenda Smith
Aug 15
13 min read

I have a theory about Morrisons. For many shoppers, it is not a supermarket they actively choose. It is the supermarket they use because it happens to be nearby.


That is not to say Morrisons is bad. It has a broad range, competitive prices, proper fresh-food counters, cafés, a loyalty scheme, British produce and some genuinely good own-brand products.



But ask someone why they specifically choose Aldi, Lidl, Waitrose, M&S, Tesco or even Sainsbury’s and you will normally get a reasonably clear answer.


  • Aldi and Lidl mean low prices.

  • Waitrose and M&S mean quality and indulgence.

  • Tesco means scale, range and Clubcard Prices.

  • Sainsbury’s occupies a slightly more premium version of the mainstream family shop.


What does Morrisons mean?


I would say: 'beige'.


It sits somewhere in the middle of everything: neither the cheapest nor the most premium; neither the largest nor the most convenient; neither a specialist food destination nor an obvious digital leader. It offers plenty of reasons to shop there, but it does not appear to own one decisive reason in the customer’s mind.


And in marketing, being broadly acceptable to everybody can become a surprisingly dangerous position.


The financial evidence suggests something is not connecting


Supermarket finances are complicated. Revenue, EBITDA, statutory profit, debt and market share measure different things, while the inclusion of fuel, wholesale and convenience operations can make direct comparisons misleading. But the broad five-year pattern is difficult to ignore.


In July 2020, Morrisons held approximately 10% of the Great British grocery market. By the middle of 2025, that had fallen to around 8.4%. Over broadly the same period, Aldi and Lidl expanded significantly, Tesco strengthened its leadership and Sainsbury’s made more modest gains.


Retail academic Professor Leigh Sparks describes the longer-term picture plainly: the discounters have advanced while Asda and Morrisons have struggled.


Aldi overtook Morrisons in 2022. By 2026, Worldpanel data placed Lidl at 8.6% against Morrisons at 8.3%, although Morrisons disputes comparisons that exclude parts of its convenience business.



This is not simply a bad year. It represents a substantial erosion of competitive position.

Morrisons’ latest trading performance does show signs of improvement. For the year ending October 2025, total revenue increased by 3.2% to £15.8 billion, with like-for-like sales growing by 2.8%. Underlying EBITDA - the operating earnings measure before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation - was maintained at £835 million.


But the statutory picture remains much less comfortable. Morrisons reported a pre-tax loss of £381 million, following a £414 million loss the previous year. Net debt had reduced to £3.17 billion, down substantially from its 2022 peak, but interest costs and the financial structure created by its 2021 private-equity takeover continue to constrain the business.


So Morrisons is not collapsing. Sales are growing and the turnaround is producing some encouraging signs. But its market position has weakened considerably while more clearly defined competitors have advanced.


That raises a marketing question as much as a financial one:


Why should somebody actively choose Morrisons?


Morrisons has strengths - but strengths are not the same as positioning


Morrisons can point to an impressive list of attributes:


  • Market Street counters

  • Butchers, bakers and fishmongers

  • British meat

  • Direct relationships with farmers and fishermen

  • Cafés

  • Competitive promotions

  • The More Card

  • Manufacturing facilities

  • Local suppliers

  • Online shopping

  • Convenience stores

  • Sustainability and community programmes


The problem is not a shortage of strengths. It is the absence of a sufficiently sharp organising idea.


This is where Morrisons’ revived “More Reasons to Shop at Morrisons” campaign becomes interesting. Originally used during Sir Ken Morrison’s era and revived in 2023, the campaign draws on recognisable brand assets: the green and yellow colours, the tree logo and the memorable jingle. Its adverts have featured fresh doughnuts, British meat, fruit and vegetables, cafés, salad bars, Market Street experts, loyalty rewards and other individual reasons to shop.


It is distinctive and memorable. Bringing back an established line was probably much smarter than inventing an entirely unfamiliar identity.


But strategically, “More Reasons” may also expose the underlying problem.


If you need to give customers seven different reasons to choose you, have you decided which reason matters most?



Before that came “Make Good Things Happen”, launched in 2021. It attempted to cover food quality, sustainability, British agriculture, communities, vulnerable people, future generations and the experience of eating together. All worthwhile subjects - but too broad to establish one precise meaning in the customer’s mind.



More recently, “Fresh from Market Street” has moved much closer to Morrisons’ most defensible advantage. It highlights the supermarket’s relationships with British farmers and fishermen, its fresh counters and the work Morrisons does before food reaches the customer.



That is the right direction. But I would go further.


Freshness should not be one campaign among several. It should become the central strategic position around which the whole Morrisons business is organised.


What would Theodore Levitt say?


In his influential 1960 article Marketing Myopia, Harvard professor Theodore Levitt argued that businesses decline when they define themselves by the products they make rather than the customer needs they serve.


His famous example was the railway companies. They thought they were in the railway business when they were really in the transportation business. Their customers did not fundamentally want trains; they wanted to get somewhere.


The same question can be applied to Morrisons:


What business is Morrisons really in?


The obvious answer is groceries. But nobody genuinely wants to spend Saturday morning walking around a supermarket buying groceries.


People want:


  • Dinner sorted

  • Their family fed

  • Confidence in the food they buy

  • Better ingredients

  • Less stress

  • More time

  • Value for their money

  • The satisfaction of cooking something enjoyable


The supermarket is merely the mechanism.


Levitt would therefore ask Morrisons to stop beginning with everything it sells and instead decide which customer need it intends to serve better than anybody else.


My answer would be:


Morrisons should become Britain’s fresh-food supermarket


Morrisons possesses a competitive strength that is far more substantial than an advertising slogan. The company says it sources and processes around half of the fresh food it sells through its own manufacturing facilities and stores.


It employs more skilled colleagues preparing food in-store than any other retailer. It buys extensively from British farmers and fishermen, operates specialist production facilities and maintains traditional Market Street counters that many competitors have reduced or removed.


Morrisons describes itself as both a foodmaker and shopkeeper. That is not manufactured marketing copy. It reflects a genuinely different operating model.


Yet I’m not convinced the average shopper understands it.


If Morrisons makes or prepares so much of its fresh food, has greater control over its provenance and quality, sources more fresh food directly from British farms than its competitors and employs real butchers, bakers and fishmongers, why isn’t that the first thing everybody associates with Morrisons?



This is the space it should own:


Britain’s Fresh Food Supermarket

Or, more boldly - subject to Morrisons being able to substantiate the superlative:


Britain’s Freshest Food Shop


The corresponding campaign could be:

Fresh Starts Here

Everything else would sit underneath that single promise:


  • Morrisons makes and prepares much of its own fresh food.

  • Its experts cut, bake, prepare and advise.

  • Its relationships with farmers and fishermen improve provenance.

  • Market Street brings visible food expertise into the store.

  • Seasonal food changes throughout the year.

  • Fresh ingredients help customers cook and eat better.

  • Control of production can support quality and value.


Instead of advertising seven unrelated reasons to shop at Morrisons, each communication would provide fresh evidence for the same reason.


  • One advert might follow a fish from the boat to the counter.

  • Another might introduce a Morrisons butcher.

  • A third could compare bread baked that morning with industrially produced alternatives.

  • In-store signage could tell customers when something was made, prepared or delivered.

  • QR codes could introduce farmers and producers.

  • Market Street could become theatrical again rather than feeling like a collection of counters gradually being managed out of existence.


Freshness would become more than a claim. It would shape product development, store layout, staffing, packaging, service, digital content and customer experience.


That is positioning: not simply saying something repeatedly, but organising the business so that the promise becomes true and noticeable.


There are other positions Morrisons could pursue


Fresh food is my preferred answer because it builds on something Morrisons already does unusually well. But there are several other viable directions - provided Morrisons commits to one rather than attempting to communicate all of them simultaneously.


1. The supermarket that gives you your evenings back


Customer: Busy professionals and dual-income families.

Customer need: “I don’t mind paying slightly more if shopping is quick and dinner is easily sorted.” They are not really buying groceries. They are buying time, convenience and reduced mental load.

Positioning: The supermarket that gives you your evenings back.

Campaign: Get Your Evening Back

This could include 15-minute dinner zones, healthy grab-and-go meals, “dinner for four under £15”, fast click and collect, an app that creates the quickest route through the store and meal plans automatically converted into shopping lists.


2. The family supermarket


Customer: Busy households with children.

Customer need: Making real family life easier rather than presenting an idealised version of it.

Positioning: Making family life simpler.

Campaign: For Real Family Life

Morrisons could create lunchbox zones, family meal bundles, birthday-party packs, children’s recipes, school-holiday solutions and dinners designed for households in which everybody inexplicably wants something different.


3. Britain’s local supermarket


Customer: People who want to support British producers and understand where their food comes from.

Customer need: Trust, provenance and a meaningful connection with producers.

Positioning: Proudly British. Proudly Local.

Campaign:Meet the Makers

Stores could feature a different local farmer, grower, cheesemaker, baker or producer each week, supported by films, recipes, sampling and QR codes. However, Morrisons would need to ensure that “local” is genuinely local to each store rather than simply using Britishness as a substitute.


4. Healthy made easy


Customer: People who want to eat better but feel overwhelmed by labels, recipes and conflicting advice.

Customer need: Help making healthier decisions without additional complexity.

Positioning: Healthy choices made simple.

Campaign: No More Guessing

This might involve clearly identified healthy baskets, straightforward colour coding, affordable recipe cards, family meal plans and a “£25 healthy week” challenge.


5. The sustainability supermarket


Customer: Environmentally conscious shoppers who still need affordability and convenience.

Customer need: The ability to reduce their environmental impact without turning shopping into a research project.

Positioning: Making sustainable shopping affordable.

The experience could include refill stations, less packaging, local and seasonal produce, food-waste rescue boxes, clearer environmental information and visible incentives for lower-waste choices.

The danger is credibility. Sustainability cannot be treated as a green advertising layer over an unchanged operating model.


6. The food-inspiration supermarket


Customer: People bored with cooking the same meals repeatedly.

Customer need: Ideas, confidence and enjoyment.

Positioning: Helping Britain love cooking again.

The campaign could combine in-store chefs, demonstrations, tastings, seasonal ingredients, recipe stations and QR-linked cooking videos. Morrisons would become somewhere to discover food, not merely somewhere to acquire it.


Why fresh food wins


Each idea contains potential. But Morrisons cannot credibly become the cheapest, healthiest, most convenient, most sustainable, most local, most family-friendly and most inspiring supermarket at the same time.


That is exactly how positioning becomes diluted.


The fresh-food territory wins because it satisfies three important tests:


  1. It is relevant to customers. People care about taste, quality, health and provenance.

  2. It is distinctive. Morrisons’ vertically integrated manufacturing, skilled foodmakers and Market Street heritage provide credible difference.

  3. It is difficult to copy. A competitor can reproduce an advert or introduce a product range. Recreating manufacturing facilities, supplier relationships, skilled counters and an established fresh-food identity is significantly harder.


Morrisons does not need to invent a new purpose. It needs to recognise, strengthen and consistently communicate the advantage already inside the business.


Putting Morrisons through The Marketing Shift™


My own framework, The Marketing Shift™, moves a business through five stages: SEE, SHAPE, STAND OUT, SPEAK and SMOOTH.



It prevents businesses from jumping immediately to a new website, advertising campaign or social-media plan before they have understood the real commercial problem.


Applied to Morrisons, it looks like this.


1. SEE: Face the commercial reality


The first stage is about looking objectively at the business, its customers, competitors, market, demand and performance.


Morrisons remains a substantial business. It generated £15.8 billion in revenue during its latest financial year, delivered £835 million in underlying EBITDA and has now recorded several consecutive quarters of positive like-for-like sales growth.


But the longer-term competitive picture is much less comfortable.


Its share of the Great British grocery market has fallen from approximately 10% in 2021 to around 8.4% in 2025. Aldi has overtaken it, Lidl has almost caught it and Tesco has strengthened its position. Morrisons has also reported significant statutory losses and continues to carry the consequences of its debt-funded private-equity takeover.


The important point is not simply that Morrisons has debt or that competitors have grown. It is that customers appear to have stronger reasons for choosing those competitors.


Aldi and Lidl own low prices. Waitrose owns premium service and quality. M&S Food owns indulgence and convenient treats. Tesco owns range, accessibility and Clubcard value. Sainsbury’s occupies a relatively clear position as a slightly more premium mainstream family supermarket.


Morrisons has many assets, but its place in the customer’s mind is less obvious.


The SEE stage therefore identifies the central problem:


Morrisons is not fundamentally short of products, shops, campaigns or operational strengths. It is short of a compelling reason to be actively chosen.


2. SHAPE: Build the offer around what customers need


The second stage is about shaping the business around customer needs rather than around the products it already happens to sell.


Morrisons could attempt to compete primarily on price, but Aldi and Lidl possess operating models specifically designed for that battle. It could compete on scale and convenience, but Tesco has a much larger store network, an exceptionally powerful loyalty ecosystem and greater commercial resources. It could move further upmarket, but Waitrose and M&S already possess stronger premium associations.


Morrisons needs to shape its proposition around the point at which a genuine customer need meets a genuine organisational strength.


Customers do not simply want “fresh departments” or “vertically integrated manufacturing”.


They want food that looks, tastes and feels fresher. They want confidence in its quality and provenance. They want expert help choosing and preparing it. They want to feel that the food they serve their families is worth the money.


Morrisons already has the foundations to serve that need. It sources and processes a significant proportion of its fresh food itself, works directly with British farmers and fishermen, operates its own manufacturing facilities and employs skilled butchers, bakers, fishmongers and other foodmakers.


The offer should therefore be shaped around a simple customer outcome:


Morrisons helps people put fresher, better food on the table.


That does not mean abandoning value, convenience, family meals, health or sustainability. It means making each of them support the same central promise.


Value becomes fresh food worth paying for. Convenience becomes fresh dinners made easier. Health becomes better fresh choices. Local sourcing becomes evidence of freshness. Market Street becomes the physical expression of the proposition.


3. STAND OUT: Own a distinctive position


This is where Morrisons must decide what it wants to own in the customer’s mind.

“

More Reasons to Shop at Morrisons” is a memorable campaign asset, but it encourages the business to communicate numerous strengths simultaneously. Fresh doughnuts, cafés, British meat, salad bars, loyalty points, price promotions and helpful colleagues may all be valid reasons to visit. Together, however, they do not necessarily establish one distinctive position.


“Make Good Things Happen” was broader still, encompassing food, communities, sustainability, suppliers and social purpose. Admirable - but too expansive to tell customers why Morrisons should be selected over another supermarket.


The strongest territory is already sitting inside the business:


Britain’s Freshest Food Shop


The claim would need to be carefully evidenced and legally substantiated, but strategically it is powerful. It gives Morrisons something clearer and more ownable than being another mainstream supermarket promising quality, value and choice.


It is supported by tangible proof:


  • Market Street and its specialist counters

  • In-store butchers, bakers and fishmongers

  • Direct relationships with British farmers and fishermen

  • Morrisons’ own food-production facilities

  • Greater control over quality and provenance

  • Fresh food prepared by skilled colleagues

  • A heritage rooted in foodmaking and market trading


Competitors could copy the words, but reproducing the underlying supply chain, skills, facilities and heritage would be considerably harder.


Morrisons would no longer be the supermarket with lots of vaguely appealing attributes.

It would be the place Britain goes for fresh food.


4. SPEAK: Communicate one idea consistently


Only after the position is settled should Morrisons decide how to communicate it.


The campaign line would be:


Fresh Starts Here


Every advertisement would tell a different story, but all would reinforce the same position.

One could follow fish from a British harbour to a Market Street counter. Another could feature a butcher preparing a cut for a family dinner. Another could show bread being baked that morning. Farmers, growers, fishermen and Morrisons foodmakers could become recognisable faces within the campaign.


Rather than listing claims, Morrisons should show the work behind the food.


The communication hierarchy would be straightforward:


Position: Britain’s Freshest Food Shop

Campaign: Fresh Starts Here

Evidence: We source it, make it, prepare it and help you enjoy it.


“More Reasons to Shop at Morrisons” does not necessarily need to disappear. It could remain as a valuable distinctive brand asset, but each “reason” should become evidence of the fresh-food position rather than an unrelated message.


More reason to visit the butcher. More reason to buy British. More reason to choose today’s bread. More reason to ask the fishmonger. More reason to cook something properly fresh.

The website, television advertising, social media, packaging, PR, seasonal campaigns and in-store signage should all speak with one voice. Price promotions would still exist, but they would no longer define the brand.


The objective is simple: when somebody hears “Morrisons”, the immediate association should be fresh food.


5. SMOOTH: Make the promise easy to experience


Positioning fails when the advertising promises something the customer cannot easily experience.


If Morrisons claims to be Britain’s freshest food shop, the entire customer journey must prove it.


Market Street should feel like the centre of the store rather than a legacy feature around its edges. Counters must be properly staffed, visually abundant and open when customers actually shop. Experts should be easy to identify and confident in offering advice. Fresh products should display useful information about provenance, preparation and when they were made or delivered.



The digital journey must support the same promise. Online customers should be able to shop by season, recipe, producer or meal. They should be able to ask for particular cuts of meat, choose how fish is prepared and turn recipes into shopping lists. Click and collect should preserve confidence in freshness rather than leaving customers wondering what somebody else will select for them.

Morrisons should then measure whether the strategy is changing behaviour - not merely whether people remember the advert.


Useful measures would include:


  • Customer association of Morrisons with fresh food

  • Perceptions of quality and value

  • Market Street footfall and sales

  • Fresh-food basket size

  • Frequency of visits

  • Customer retention

  • Growth among people who enjoy cooking

  • Market-share recovery

  • The number of customers actively choosing Morrisons rather than using it solely because it is nearby


That completes the shift.


Morrisons moves from seeing a worrying commercial reality, to shaping its offer around a valuable customer need, standing out through an advantage it can credibly own, speaking about that advantage consistently and smoothing the customer experience so that the promise is delivered.


SEE: Morrisons is losing ground and lacks a clear place in the customer’s mind.

SHAPE: Build the proposition around fresher, better food.

STAND OUT: Become Britain’s Freshest Food Shop.

SPEAK: Bring it to life through Fresh Starts Here.

SMOOTH: Make freshness visible and easy to experience at every touchpoint.


That is not simply a new advertising campaign. It is a strategic repositioning of the entire business.


The Morrisons Test


There is a useful lesson here for every small-business owner.


When reviewing your own marketing, ask:


  1. Who is the business really for?

  2. What customer problem does it solve?

  3. What does it own in the customer’s mind?

  4. What emotional outcome is the customer actually buying?

  5. If the product disappeared tomorrow, what customer need would still exist?


If your answer is a long list of products, services, qualities and audiences, you may have the same problem as Morrisons.


You can have excellent people, good products, strong values, competitive prices and dozens of reasons to buy. But if the customer cannot immediately understand why they should choose you instead of somebody else, those strengths become noise.


Morrisons is not short of reasons.


It is short of one reason powerful enough to organise everything else around.


For me, that reason is fresh food.


Morrisons: Fresh Starts Here.


Sources and further reading:


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
Case Study: Anglia Kitchens & Bedrooms

From selling kitchens to selling the home you love Strategy · Positioning · Customer Segmentation · Campaign Development · Customer Experience · Marketing Investment The situation Anglia Kitchens & Be

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page