Why More Marketing Isn't Growing Your Business (And AI Could Be Making It Worse)

Over sixty years ago, marketing professor Theodore Levitt wrote one of the most influential business articles ever published: Marketing Myopia (myopia = short sightedness).
His central argument was remarkably simple. Businesses don't usually fail because demand disappears. They fail because they define themselves too narrowly. They become obsessed with the products and services they sell instead of the value customers are actually trying to buy (their needs).
The railway companies thought they were in the railway business, not the transport business. They got overtaken by cars. Hollywood believed it was in the movie business, not the entertainment business. It got overtaken by TV.
They missed enormous opportunities while more customer-focused competitors overtook them.
Fast forward to 2026, and I believe we're seeing a new form of marketing myopia emerge.
Not just product/service myopia.
Technology myopia.
AI myopia.
And perhaps most worryingly of all, marketing tactic myopia.

For ambitious managing directors and charity leaders trying to grow organisations in an increasingly noisy world, this should be setting alarm bells ringing.
We've become obsessed with the tools
Every week there seems to be another "essential" marketing tactic.
LinkedIn newsletters.
Instagram Reels.
TikTok.
Threads.
Personal branding.
SEO.
Podcasts.
Email automation.
AI-generated blogs.
ChatGPT.
Claude.
Gemini.
The list grows longer every month.
Business owners are bombarded with promises that the latest platform, algorithm or AI tool will transform their marketing overnight.
It rarely does.
Instead, many organisations end up spending thousands of pounds and hundreds of hours producing more content than ever before without ever asking the most important question.
Why are we doing this?
Marketing has quietly become a checklist of activities rather than a strategic business function.
That's exactly the kind of thinking my friend Levitt warned us about.
AI isn't creating the problem. It's accelerating it.
I love Generative AI.
I use it every single day.
It helps me research faster, challenge my thinking, improve first drafts and analyse ideas more deeply than ever before.
But AI is only an amplifier.
It makes good marketing better.
It also makes bad marketing happen much faster.
If your marketing strategy is weak, AI helps you create poor content at industrial scale.
If you don't understand your customers, AI allows you to misunderstand them more efficiently.
If your business lacks differentiation, AI enables you to produce hundreds of posts saying exactly the same thing as everybody else.
Technology doesn't replace thinking.
It simply accelerates whatever thinking already exists.
Most businesses aren't suffering from a marketing problem
They're suffering from a demand problem.
One of the questions I often ask clients is this:
"What level of demand actually exists for what you're selling?"
It's surprising how few business owners can answer it.
Philip Kotler identified eight different states of demand decades ago, ranging from negative demand through to excessive demand.
Yet most businesses jump straight to tactics.
Sales are falling?
"Let's run Facebook Ads."
Need more enquiries?
"Let's post every day on LinkedIn."
Competitor launched a podcast?
"We need a podcast."
The assumption is always that marketing activity is the answer.
Sometimes it is.
Very often it isn't.
Perhaps your market has changed.
Perhaps customer priorities have shifted.
Perhaps you're targeting the wrong audience altogether.
Or perhaps your offer simply isn't valuable enough anymore.
No amount of AI-generated content can solve the wrong strategic problem.
Consultants aren't always helping
This is the uncomfortable part.
Many consultants unintentionally reinforce marketing myopia.
After all, it's much easier to sell a website than a strategic rethink.
It's easier to sell social media management than customer research.
It's easier to promise thirty LinkedIn posts a month than ask difficult questions about whether the organisation is even positioned correctly.
Tactics are tangible.
Strategy is harder.
It requires curiosity.
It requires evidence.
It requires uncomfortable conversations.
Sometimes the answer isn't "do more marketing."
Sometimes it's:
Change your positioning.
Redesign your service.
Stop targeting everyone.
Increase your prices.
Launch something new.
Stop offering something altogether.
Those decisions don't always fit neatly into a monthly marketing retainer.
But they're often the decisions that transform organisations.
Marketing should influence business decisions
One of my biggest frustrations is that marketing is still treated as the communications department.
The people who "do the socials."
The ones who make brochures look nice.
The email people.
In reality, marketing should shape almost every significant business decision.
Who should we serve?
What problems matter most?
What value should we create?
How should we differentiate?
Where should we invest?
What should we stop doing?
Only after answering those questions should we decide whether we need LinkedIn, Google Ads, AI-generated blogs or anything else.
The tactics should always flow from the strategy.
Never the other way round.
This is why I developed The Marketing Shift™
After working with hundreds of organisations over the last twenty years, I noticed something.
The businesses making the best decisions weren't necessarily spending the most on marketing.
They were thinking differently.
Instead of chasing shiny new tactics, they stepped back first.
They understood their customers.
They examined demand.
They made deliberate strategic choices.
Only then did they build a marketing plan.
That's exactly why I developed The Marketing Shift™.
It's designed to help business leaders move away from reactive marketing activity and towards confident, evidence-based marketing decisions.
Because marketing isn't about posting more content.
It's about making better business decisions.
Levitt's message has never mattered more
Theodore Levitt couldn't have imagined ChatGPT. He never experienced AI-generated video, automated content creation or predictive marketing software. Yet his warning feels astonishingly modern.
Businesses become vulnerable whenever they focus more on what they produce than the value they create. Today, I would add another warning.
Businesses become vulnerable whenever they become more interested in marketing technology than marketing strategy.
AI will undoubtedly transform marketing.
But it won't replace customer understanding.
It won't replace strategic thinking.
And it certainly won't replace leadership.
The organisations that thrive over the next decade won't necessarily be the ones using the most AI.
They'll be the ones using it in service of a clear strategy, a deep understanding of customer demand and a compelling value proposition.
That's not old-fashioned thinking.
It's timeless marketing.
Ready to stop chasing tactics?
If your marketing feels busy but isn't delivering the results you'd hoped for, it might be time to step back before charging forwards.
My Marketing Strategy Intensive is designed for ambitious managing directors, founders and charity CEOs who want to make smarter marketing decisions - not simply produce more marketing.
Together we'll assess your market, understand customer demand, identify where you're becoming myopic, and build a practical strategy that fits your organisation's goals.
Book a Marketing Strategy Intensive today and start making marketing decisions that create long-term growth, not just short-term activity.
.png)



Comments